Cherry Butter – 7 Reasons You’ll Love This Irresistible Homemade Recipe

Sharing is caring!

Nothing captures the essence of summer quite like vibrant jars of homemade cherry butter lovingly preserved and lined up on your pantry shelf. If you’ve ever wondered how to capture that sun-ripened sweetness or need a new canning project that will spark joy all winter long, you’re in the right place. Today, we’re diving deep into the enchanting world of Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars—a recipe that promises unbeatable flavor, a silky-smooth texture, and enough ruby-red color to make any breakfast or dessert feel extra special.

The deep red of freshly made cherry butter is both luscious and striking—a rich, gem-like hue that instantly hints at the bold flavor within. Imagine spooning this smooth, glossy spread over toast, swirling it into yogurt, or using it as a sweet-acidic counterpoint to sharp cheeses. Whether you’re new to preserving or looking to perfect your cherry butter game, this Cherry Butter recipe guarantees a batch packed with vibrant cherry notes and a hint of lemony brightness. Alongside the easy-to-follow instructions, I’ll share pro tips, delectable serving ideas, and practical storage solutions to ensure your cherry butter remains the crown jewel of your preserves collection.

Whether you crave a nostalgic kitchen project or simply want to savor cherries at their peak, read on to discover why Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars is a must-try recipe for cooks of all skill levels and fruit lovers everywhere.

Table of Contents

Why You’ll Love Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars

• Bursting with pure cherry flavor—no artificial ingredients or fillers
• Beautiful, deep red color makes an eye-catching addition to your table
• Versatile—delicious on toast, pancakes, yogurt, in desserts, or paired with cheese
• Budget-friendly way to enjoy the taste of cherries year-round
• Easy to scale for small batches or big preserving days
• Makes a heartfelt, homemade gift for friends and family
• Stores well—with proper canning, enjoy it for months!

Ingredients for Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars

True homemade magic begins with the best ingredients. To achieve the smooth consistency and rich, tangy flavor that make this cherry butter irresistible, start with ripe, sweet cherries.

• 3 ½ pounds sweet cherries (about 6 cups, pitted and chopped): For exquisite flavor and texture, choose plump, ripe cherries—Bing, Rainier, or any favorite variety.
• 2 cups granulated sugar, divided: Sugar acts as a natural preservative while enhancing the innate sweetness of the cherries. You’ll use most at the start and reserve a portion to adjust sweetness after tasting.
• Juice of 1 lemon: Adds crucial acidity to balance sweetness and sharpens the bright fruitiness of the cherries.

Quality Matters

Choose cherries free of blemishes, soft spots, or mold. The richer the color and firmer the fruit, the more flavorful your cherry butter will be. Organic or locally sourced cherries often have exceptional taste, especially if picked at peak ripeness.

Note on sugar: Don’t worry if you’re cutting down on sugar—the recipe offers flexibility in sweetness, which we’ll discuss in the substitutions section.

Necessary Tools

• Large saucepan or jam pot: Essential for simmering your cherry butter down gently and evenly. Stainless steel or enameled surfaces are best to prevent discoloration or off-flavors.
• Cherry pitter or small paring knife: Streamline the process of removing pits from pounds of cherries without damaging the fruit.
• Cutting board & sharp knife: For chopping cherries evenly.
• Wooden spoon or heatproof spatula: Sturdy enough for frequent stirring—you’ll want to keep everything moving so nothing sticks.
• Immersion blender, food processor, or food mill: For pureeing the cooked cherries into a silky-smooth butter (immersion blenders minimize mess).
• Canning jars with lids and rings: Wide-mouth jars in half-pint or pint size work perfectly, with screw-on lids for an airtight seal.
• Jar lifter and canning funnel: Make filling jars cleaner and safer, especially when working with hot preserves.
• Clean damp cloths: To wipe jar rims before sealing—an important step to keep your preserves shelf-stable.

If you’ve never canned before, don’t be intimidated. Once you have these basic tools, most fruit preserving recipes—including cherry butter—will be at your fingertips.

Ingredient Additions & Substitutions

Making Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars is delicious in its classic form, but it’s also incredibly adaptable to your pantry and tastes. Here’s how to make it your own:

• Cherry Varieties: Sweet cherries (like Bing or Lapins) produce a dark red, deeply flavored butter, but tart cherries (like Montmorency) can be substituted for a brighter, tangier spread. Tart cherries may need extra sugar—taste as you go.
• Sugar Swaps: Looking to cut refined sugar? Try replacing all or part of the sugar with honey or maple syrup for earthy undertones. Coconut sugar or raw cane sugar can add depth and a subtle caramel note. If using less sugar or sugar alternatives, remember that shelf life may be slightly reduced, so refrigerate and use more quickly.
• Citrus Options: Lemon juice provides acidity and brightens the flavor, but you can swap in lime juice for a zesty twist or add the zest of the lemon for an extra pop of citrus aroma.
• Spice It Up: For a warm, spiced cherry butter, add ½ teaspoon cinnamon, a pinch of ground cloves, or a dash of cardamom during the simmer. Vanilla extract (added after cooking) brings a sweet floral note.
• Extra Fruits: You can incorporate a handful of raspberries, blackberries, or even a diced apple for subtle complexity. Just simmer with the cherries and proceed with the recipe.
• Alcoholic Flair: For an adult treat, try stirring in a splash of cherry brandy or bourbon after pureeing—but before canning—for depth and aroma.

No matter your adaptations or dietary needs, this Cherry Butter recipe aims to be vastly customizable. Just remember: consistently taste as you go, especially when changing sugar or acid, to achieve your ideal cherry butter flavor.

How to Make Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars

Crafting cherry butter is a joyful, sensory experience—from the scent of simmering fruit to the rich color building as the butter thickens. Here’s your detailed roadmap for achieving that mesmerizing, glossy spread you see in the photo above, complete with its deep garnet hue and irresistible silkiness.

Step 1: Prepare the Cherries

Rinse cherries under cool running water and pat them dry. Remove and discard the pits using a cherry pitter or paring knife. Chop the pitted cherries roughly—a range of sizes is fine, but 1/2-inch pieces cook down best. Transfer chopped cherries into a large bowl.

Step 2: Combine Cherries and Sugar

Place chopped cherries in a large saucepan or jam pot. Add 1½ cups of the granulated sugar. Stir well to coat the fruit, then let the cherries and sugar rest while you gather the remaining ingredients and tools. This brief maceration draws out juices for a jammy base.

Step 3: Start Cooking

Over medium-high heat, bring the cherry-sugar mixture to a gentle boil. Stir frequently with a heatproof spatula or wooden spoon to prevent the fruit from sticking. As the cherries heat, their skins break down, releasing deep crimson juices. The mixture’s color will intensify dramatically.

Step 4: Simmer and Reduce

Reduce heat to low and allow the mixture to simmer, uncovered, for at least one hour. Stir occasionally to prevent burning, taking care to scrape the bottom and sides of your pot. As the moisture evaporates, the cherry mix will become glossy and thick, reducing in volume by nearly half.

Step 5: Puree for Velvet-Smooth Texture

Remove the pot from heat once the cherries are soft and the mixture is deeply colored. Puree using an immersion blender directly in the pot, or carefully transfer to a food processor/food mill. Process until the cherry butter is luxuriously smooth with no visible chunks.

Step 6: Final Sweetness & Lemon Brightness

Taste your cherry butter. If you prefer it a bit sweeter, add up to ½ cup more granulated sugar. Stir in the freshly squeezed lemon juice and blend thoroughly. Return to the heat briefly, stirring, just long enough to dissolve sugar and incorporate lemon juice.

Step 7: Thickness Test

Scoop up a spoonful of cherry butter and turn the spoon sideways. If the mixture holds its shape in a soft mound, it’s done. If it drips or runs off quickly, simmer a few extra minutes and test again.

Step 8: Fill Jars and Seal

Ladle hot cherry butter into prepared jars, leaving ¼” headspace. Wipe rims with a damp cloth, then secure lids and rings fingertip-tight. If storing in the fridge, let jars cool completely before sealing.

Step 9: Process for Long-Term Storage (Optional)

For shelf-stable cherry butter, process jars in a boiling water bath for 15 minutes (add five more minutes if above 6,000 feet elevation). Let jars cool on a towel, then check lids for a secure seal before labeling and storing.

Serving Suggestions

Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars is unbelievably versatile. Here are succulent ways to enjoy it:

• Spread thickly on warm, crusty sourdough, toast, or English muffins for a morning treat
• Dollop on pancakes, waffles, or crepes for a fruity breakfast upgrade
• Swirl into Greek yogurt, oatmeal, or cottage cheese
• Layer in parfaits or use as a filling between cake layers or in thumbprint cookies
• Serve alongside sharp cheeses and meats on a charcuterie board
• Warm and drizzle as a sauce over ice cream, cheesecake, or chocolate desserts
• Gift a jar to a friend or neighbor with a ribbon and handwritten label—perfect for holidays and hostess gifts

The deep, jewel-like red and creamy gloss of your cherry butter (as seen in the photograph) adds instant beauty and sophistication to any table.

Pro Tips & Tricks

• Pit cherries efficiently: Invest in a cherry pitter if you plan to preserve cherries regularly—it’s a game changer.
• Prevent scorching: Stir often and don’t rush the simmering. Use low heat for a smooth, flawless texture.
• Adjust sugar and acid to taste: Taste before canning, especially when substituting different cherry varieties or sweeteners—remember, less sugar may affect shelf life.
• Batch size flexibility: Double or halve the recipe as desired, but simmering time may vary. Always cook until properly thickened.
• Test consistency: Use the “mound on a spoon” trick or let a spoonful cool on a cold plate to check set before canning.
• Clean jars are crucial: Sterilize jars and lids in boiling water or run them through a hot dishwasher cycle. Wipe rims before sealing.
• Use a canning funnel: Reduces drips and keeps jar rims clean to ensure a good seal.
• Customize flavors: Experiment with spices, vanilla, or extra citrus—just keep additions safe and in moderation.

Confidence grows with every batch. Soon, you’ll have perfect cherry butter every time!

Storage Instructions

Proper storage ensures that your Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars tastes as fresh as the day you made it.

• Refrigerator: If you’re skipping the water bath canning step, store in the fridge for up to 3 weeks. Always use a clean utensil when dipping into the jar.
• Freezer: Cherry butter can be frozen in airtight, freezer-safe containers for up to 6 months. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before use.
• Shelf-stable: After water bath processing, store sealed jars in a cool, dark place (pantry or cupboard) for up to one year. Once a jar is opened, refrigerate and use within 3 weeks.

Check your jars periodically. Discard any with popped lids, off smell, or signs of spoilage.

General Information

Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars originates from classic fruit preservation methods. Fruit butters have a long history in home canning, prized for their easy texture and intense flavor—less sweet than jams, but silkier and deeply concentrated. The word “butter” refers not to dairy but to the spreadable smoothness and luxurious finish.

Cherries are packed with antioxidants and natural pectin, making them ideal for butters that set beautifully without commercial thickeners. This Cherry Butter recipe celebrates simplicity: just ripe fruit, sugar, and lemon—flavors you can trust and pronounce. Canning brings the nostalgia of old-fashioned kitchens into today’s homes and connects us to a centuries-old tradition of savoring fruit all year long.

FAQs

Can I use frozen cherries instead of fresh?

Yes! Thaw the cherries completely, drain excess liquid, and continue as directed. Frozen cherries work wonderfully outside cherry season.

Can I reduce the sugar in this Cherry Butter recipe?

You can use less sugar, but remember sugar preserves flavor and extends shelf life. If you reduce sugar significantly or use a sugar substitute, treat even canned jars as refrigerator/freezer preserves.

Is canning cherry butter absolutely necessary?

No, you can store it in the fridge for 2-3 weeks or freeze for up to 6 months. Canning just makes it pantry-safe and easier to gift or store longer.

What if my cherry butter is too thin or too thick?

If too thin after cooking, continue simmering to reduce more. If it’s overly thick, stir in a few teaspoons of water or cherry juice until desired consistency is reached.

Can I add spices or liquor?

Absolutely! Add warm spices like cinnamon or a splash of brandy for depth—just do so after pureeing (and before canning) to best preserve flavor.

Do I need pectin for cherry butter?

No, cherries have natural pectin and the long, slow cook thickens the butter beautifully without added thickeners.

Conclusion

Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars is a show-stopping homemade preserve that brings out the purest essence of cherries and the old-fashioned joy of home canning. Whether you spoon it on breakfast, swirl it into desserts, or share a jar as a heartfelt gift, you’re guaranteed vivid flavors, long-lasting freshness, and a touch of summer in every bite. Give this Cherry Butter recipe a try—you’ll be amazed by the vibrant, glossy spread you can make at home.

Nutritional Information

One tablespoon serving of Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars provides about:

• Calories: 45-55 (varies with sugar level)
• Fat: 0g
• Carbohydrates: 12-14g (mostly from cherries and sugar)
• Sugar: 11-13g (natural and added)
• Protein: 0g
• Fiber: 0.5-1g (from pureed cherries)
• Vitamin C: Cherries and lemon juice provide immune-supporting antioxidants

This spread is naturally gluten-free, vegan, and—when made with less refined sugar or natural sweeteners—a healthy way to preserve fruit. As with all sweet preserves, enjoy in moderation for the perfect balance of flavor and nutrition.

Ready to give Homemade Cherry Butter: Preserving Fruit in Jars a try? Your summer bounty awaits, and your taste buds will thank you all year long!

Print