The Best Easter Poke Cake: How I Turned Box Mix Into a Holiday Showstopper

Sharing is caring!

Have you ever found yourself volunteered for something you’ve never actually done before? Last Easter, my sister Rachel announced to our entire family group chat: “Sarah makes this amazing Easter poke cake!” Twenty-three heart emojis later, I was panicking. The problem? I’d never made a poke cake in my life.

That night, I fell down a Pinterest rabbit hole searching for Easter poke cake recipes, thinking “How hard could it be?” Turns out, pretty hard when you have no idea what you’re doing. But three years and many cake disasters later, this Easter poke cake has become my signature spring dessert—the one thing my mother-in-law actually asks me how to make.

If you’re looking for a dessert that screams “spring” while secretly being almost foolproof, this Easter poke cake is your answer. And I’m going to tell you every mistake I’ve made so you don’t have to.

Easter Poke Cake Ingredients List

For the Cake Base:

• 1 box white cake mix (plus ingredients listed on the box: typically eggs, oil, and water)
• Gel food coloring in pastels (pink, blue, yellow)

Don’t have gel colors? Regular food coloring works but you’ll need way less than you think. Like, literally one drop. Trust me on this—I’ve created some psychedelic monstrosities in my learning process.

For the Filling:

• 1 package (3 oz) instant vanilla pudding mix
• 1¾ cups cold milk (whole milk makes it richer, but 2% works fine—I’ve tried both)

Can’t do dairy? My friend Leah makes this with almond milk. The pudding doesn’t set quite as firmly, but it still soaks into the cake beautifully.

For the Topping:

• 1 container (8 oz) Cool Whip, thawed
• 1 cup white chocolate chips
• 1 teaspoon vegetable oil
• Easter sprinkles, candy eggs, and decorations

Homemade whipped cream is NOT a good substitute here—I learned this the hard way when mine melted into a sad puddle during my in-laws’ Easter dinner. Stick with the shelf-stable stuff for this recipe.

Timing: When to Make Easter Poke Cake (And When to Lie About How Long It Took)

• Preparation time: 25 minutes (that includes dividing and coloring batter, which takes longer than you think when you’re being careful)
• Cooking time: 30 minutes for baking, plus 2-3 hours chilling time
• Total time: About 3 hours (though most of that is waiting while it chills)

The beauty of this Easter poke cake is that it actually tastes better made a day ahead. The pudding fully sets and melds with the cake, creating this incredible texture that’s somehow both moist and light. This revelation saved Easter two years ago when my oven decided to die on Easter morning. I’d already made my cake the night before, so while everyone else was panicking about how to cook the ham, I was calmly arranging candy eggs on my perfectly chilled cake.

When people ask how long it took me to make, I usually add about 30 minutes to the actual time. It just sounds more impressive that way.

How to make Easter Poke Cake

Step 1: Create Your Pastel Batter

Preheat your oven to 350°F and grease a 9×13-inch baking dish. Mix the white cake batter according to the package. I measure the water exactly—this is not the time for “that looks about right.”

Divide the batter equally between three bowls. I use my actual measuring cups to ensure even distribution—about 1⅓ cups per bowl.

Here’s where things get critical: Add ONE tiny dab of gel food coloring to each bowl using a toothpick—pink in one, blue in another, yellow in the third. Stir each until the color is uniform.

My first attempt looked like it was colored with highlighters. My husband Mike walked into the kitchen, looked at the violently bright batter, and asked, “Are we sure that’s edible?” The colors should be whisper-pale; they’ll intensify during baking.

Step 2: Create Marble Magic (Without Creating Mud)

Drop spoonfuls of each colored batter into the pan, alternating colors. I like to create a checkerboard pattern, but honestly, random works too. When my daughter Emma helps with this step, our cake looks like colorful polka dots before swirling.

Once all the batter is in the pan, give it a gentle tap on the counter to remove air bubbles.

Now for the most crucial step: Take a butter knife and make exactly THREE figure-eight motions through the batter. This is the make-or-break moment! Resist the urge to keep swirling.

My sister watched me make this cake last spring and physically tried to grab the knife from me to “finish mixing it.” I had to slap her hand away. When we cut into the perfectly marbled cake later, she admitted I was right.

Step 3: Bake It Perfect (Or Close Enough)

Bake according to the package directions, usually 25-30 minutes, until a toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean. My oven runs hot, so I check my cake at 23 minutes.

Let the cake cool for exactly 10 minutes—set a timer! This is the perfect temperature for poking. Too hot and your cake will fall apart; too cool and the pudding won’t soak in properly.

Step 4: The Crucial Step: Poke and Pour

Using a wooden spoon handle, poke holes all over your cake, about 1 inch apart. This part is weirdly therapeutic—like bubble wrap popping for adults.

The most crucial tip: Don’t poke all the way to the bottom of the pan! I made this mistake at my friend Diana’s house when we were making a poke cake for her daughter’s birthday. When we poured the pudding over, it all seeped under the cake, creating what Diana’s husband now refers to as “The Great Pudding Flood of 2022.”

In a separate bowl, whisk together the pudding mix and cold milk for 2 minutes. Let it sit for 45 seconds until it just barely begins to thicken.

Slowly pour the pudding over your cake, focusing on filling the holes. Two years ago, I whisked the pudding and immediately poured it over my beautiful cake. It was still too liquid and ran everywhere, creating pudding lakes around the edges. My daughter Emma (age 8) looked at it and said, “Mommy, I think your cake is crying.”

Now I time the pudding on my phone while staring intensely at it, which led my husband to comment last Easter, “You look like you’re diffusing a bomb, not making a cake.”

Step 5: Chill It (The Cake, Then Yourself)

Refrigerate the cake for at least 2 hours, or overnight. Last Easter, I made mine the day before, and it was the best version I’ve ever made.

While it’s chilling, I usually have a glass of wine. Cake making is stressful business, especially when your mother-in-law has requested it specifically.

Step 6: Top It Off Like You Know What You’re Doing

Spread the Cool Whip evenly over the chilled cake. I use an offset spatula for this, but a regular spatula or even the back of a spoon works fine.

I used to be a fresh whipped cream snob. “Oh, I only use organic heavy cream that I whip by hand,” I’d say smugly. Then came the Easter of 2021, when I proudly covered my cake with freshly whipped cream right before my in-laws arrived. By the time we served dessert two hours later, the cream had collapsed into a sad, weeping mess. My niece looked at it and said, “What happened to the pretty cake?”

Now I use Cool Whip without shame or apology. That stuff could survive the apocalypse and still hold its peaked perfection.

For the white chocolate drizzle, combine white chocolate chips and vegetable oil in a microwave-safe bowl. Microwave at 50% power in 30-second bursts, stirring between each, until melted and smooth.

Two Easters ago, I tried to melt white chocolate in the microwave on high power. The result was a seized, grainy mess that smelled like scorched plastic. My husband walked in, took one look at my face, and silently poured me a glass of the good wine we were saving for dinner.

Transfer the melted chocolate to a zip-top bag, snip a tiny corner, and drizzle over your cake in whatever pattern makes you happy. For last Sunday’s cake, my daughter Emma helped me drizzle it. Her zigzag pattern looked much more professional than my usual “drunk spider” aesthetic. Kids and their superior fine motor skills.

Add sprinkles and Easter decorations while the chocolate is still wet so they stick to your cake. After spending $35 on specialty Easter cake decorations my first year (which my cat Milo promptly batted onto the floor), I discovered the wonder of dollar store Easter decorations.

Nutritional Information: The Numbers No One Wants to See

Look, I’m going to be straight with you. This is not health food. It’s a celebration cake. But if you must know:

• Calories: About 320 per serving (assuming 12 servings)
• Fat: 14g (9g saturated)
• Carbohydrates: 45g
• Protein: 3g
• Sugar: 32g
• Sodium: 310mg

I once tried to calculate the exact nutritional information, but halfway through adding up all the numbers, I decided I didn’t want to know and abandoned the project. It’s Easter. Live a little.

More Easter Delights:

Planning a full Easter menu? Here are a couple of other recipes that would be perfect additions to your celebration:

• For another stunning dessert centerpiece, try my Easter Swirl Pie. It’s as beautiful as it is delicious.
• If you need a simpler, kid-friendly treat, my Easter Chocolate Chip Cookies are always a hit. They’re easy to make and perfect for little helpers.

Print